If you’re reading this
post, let me start off by saying “thank you.”
You all know that I’ve been a consistently inconsistent dieter and exerciser
for the last 10 years. You may recall that I successfully completed the VIP
fitness program in late 2015 where I lost 36 lbs. I’m sure none of you will be surprised to learn
that I have gained back 30 of those 36 lbs.
I have nothing bad to say about the program, it was simply unsustainable
for the long term, and as soon as I returned to more normal eating patterns,
the weight came right back on. What that
program did for me, however, was prove that I could do it. I could stick with a program and be
successful at losing weight, something that I had not been able to do
previously.
Over the last 5 years,
as my weight started to creep back up, I’ve tried to replicate the success I
had with VIP to no avail. Then, three
years ago I started having issues with chronic back pain, ending up in the
hospital in March of 2018 and again in April of 2019. The back pain is far from resolved and in
fact after months of physical therapy, 6 rounds of pain injections, and a rhizotomy
ablation that has not afforded me the desired relief, I know back surgery is in
the offing for me.
Recently, I visited my
doctor for my annual exam, and for the first time he told me it’s time to lose
weight. Though I’ve tipped the scales at
more than I weigh now, this is the first time a doctor has ever told me to lose
weight. I complained to him about my
back, and I told him that I can’t exercise because of it, announcing that “I can’t
even walk around the block!” I also advised
him that I can’t lose weight by changing my diet alone, I’ve tried that in the
past, but it doesn’t work unless I incorporate exercise. He listened to my tale of woe excuses,
and said that he hears that all the time, but it isn’t true, saying “You can
and should lose weight by changing your diet, if you do it right.” He then suggested that I look into a program
called Bright Lines Eating (“BLE”) which was developed by a scientist named
Susan Peirce Thompson. When I visited the website, two things struck me: 1)
this program seems tailor-made for a “rule follower” like me, and 2) it isn’t
really a diet, it’s a way of eating and thinking about food.
Though I found some
negative online reviews about this program, I’ve decided to give it a try
anyway, it comes recommended by my own doctor who I trust, so there must be at
least some merit to the program. I downloaded a copy of Susan Thompson’s book
from the library and purchased the 14 day trial program. When I’m done with
that, I may decide to join an 8 week “BLE Boot Camp” or I can keep going at it
on my own. I’ve calculated that I need at least 10 weeks to get to my “goal
weight” or as Susan Thompson refers to it, my “right sized body,” a phrase
which I kind of like.
A Brief Summary of the
Bright Line Eating Program
The program is really
straight-forward with 4 main pillars or “bright lines.” For the rule-follower in me, these “bright
lines” or “rules” make sense. Here they are:
1. No sugar. This rule really means no “added” sugar of any kind, and
it also means no artificial sweeteners, natural sweeteners, honey, maple syrup,
agave or the like. If sugar or some other sweetener is listed as one of
the first 3 ingredients in a product, do not eat it.
2. No flour of any kind. This includes almond flour, rice
flour, whole wheat flour, and any other flour. Susan points out that the
plant that the flour comes from is not the issue, it’s the processing used to
create the “flour” that is problematic. As with sweeteners, if the word flour
is in the first 3 ingredients of a product, it’s not allowed.
3. No snacking; Eat only 3 meals at regular meal
times. Snacking between
meals, after dinner or before a meal starts is off-limits. This rule runs
contrary to some other programs that suggest you should graze all day to keep
your metabolism running. This no
snacking rule also prohibits bites, licks, and tastes (“BLTs”) while you are
preparing a meal. According to Susan, the first bite of a meal should be when
you sit down to eat. This rule is a hard one for me to follow, I’m constantly
taking bites here and there as I make the kids’ lunches or make dinner for the
family. I’m also guilty of eating while cleaning up after dinner… for example,
a bite of chicken left on a kid’s plate, a few bites of spaghetti left in the
strainer which is not enough to save, but I don’t want to see it go to
waste. These are the BLTs that add up to
excess, unwanted calories.
4. Quantities. The BLE weight-loss plan specifies which foods from
which food groups and their quantities you should eat for each meal. These food
groups are protein, fruit, veggie, and fat. I’ll post a list of foods from each
food group later.
5. No alcohol. I said there were only 4 rules, but I’m including a
fifth in my list. Susan Thompson lumps alcohol with the “No Sugar” rule
because the body processes alcohol the same way it processes sugar, but for my
rule-follower brain, I need a specific “bright line” for alcohol, especially
wine. I had already decided at the end
of last year that I would follow the recent “Dry January” trend, so at least initially
the no alcohol has not been an issue for me.
Let
me be clear, I know in my heart of hearts, that I will not be able to give up
wine or alcohol for the rest of my life.
And perhaps that mind-set is setting me up for failure, but this is my
journey. What I’ve taken from the
research I’ve done regarding BLE is that for today (and until February 6), I
have committed to the “No alcohol” rule. I don’t know what the future will
bring, but for today, I am committed, and I am committed to re-commit each day.
That’s all any of us can do… live for today, because for each of us, tomorrow is
not guaranteed. To help with this daily re-commitment, the BLE program offers
some strategies.
Commitment Strategies
1. Meal plan in a food journal the night
before. One of the more important aspects of this way of eating is to plan
ahead and then follow the plan without deviating from it. The “without deviating” part of the rule is
especially hard for me. All I can say
is, I am doing my best not to deviate, and if I have the right foods in my
fridge, it makes it easier to follow the plan and less likely to fail. This
part of the program isn’t all that different from other programs, like WW, that
have you track your food throughout the day, I’ve tried that,
unsuccessfully. Here, the food
journaling or tracking is reversed, you do it ahead of time and commit to
following it. Again, my rule-following brain likes to have a plan to follow.
2. Wake up, meditate, and set your intention
for the day. I actually love this strategy. Since last March, I’ve had real
difficulty getting out of bed in the morning because of my back pain. The only way I could get out of bed was by
doing some stretching exercises I learned in physical therapy. When therapy ended in September, I continued
doing these stretching exercises. Later,
I started doing Yin Yoga, and now I incorporate a 15-20 minute Yoga routine
into my morning upon waking. Because I
was doing that anyway, it was easy to add meditation and intention setting into
my morning Yoga routine. I have to get up earlier than I would like, but I
enjoy this routine so much, I don’t mind the early alarm.
3. Be accountable. This is where you all
come in to play. The BLE program
encourages participants to be public with their commitment. I’m certain that
this is simply a marketing strategy for BLE to gain more participants. So let
me be clear, I’m not asking anyone to buy anything or join me in the program, I’m
simply looking for people to share my experience with me because I do believe
there’s merit to the accountability portion.
4. Keep track. Keeping track of my
progress is another aspect of this program that I enjoy. I started sporadically keeping a bullet
journal in June of 2016. I re-committed
to this way of journaling in October of 2019 and have kept up with it
consistently since then. Now, I’ve
incorporated the tenets of BLE into my bullet journal. There’s something satisfying about seeing my
daily progress in black and white, or in my color scheme, blue and red. I’ll
write a bullet journal post later.
This
post has gotten pretty long, so if you made it this far, again I’ll say “Thank
you!” If you did make it this far,
please post a comment below so I know who you are. After writing all of this, it
occurred to me that I should add 2 more rules based on my personal experiences:
1) Drink water. This rule is a carry-over
from VIP fitness. BLE talks about the
importance of drinking water in order to flush out the toxins in your body, but
it’s not really emphasized, and I couldn’t find a specific amount to
drink. I’ll have to go back and look at
my VIP notes to see how much water Jerry recommends, as of this writing I
couldn’t find it. The last rule I’m adding is “Don’t Quit Trying.” This rule
is modified from an old “Quit Smoking” campaign, “Don’t Quit Quitting.” Not
that I’ve ever been a smoker, but I think the sentiment works in this instance;
It’s ok not be perfect, just don’t give up trying to be.